Vision 2007, LLC v. Lexstar Dev. and Const. Co., LLC

by
Petitioner entered into a contract with respondent for the construction of a hotel. After seventeen months of work on the project, petitioner terminated the contract with respondent and respondent subsequently filed a lien against the hotel property for amounts it claimed remained owing. Petitioner filed a petition to strike the lien pursuant to Wyo. Stat. Ann. 29-1-311(b), which the district court denied on the ground that petitioner failed to prove respondent knew, when it filed its claim of lien, that the lien was groundless or contained a material misstatement or false claim. Petitioner appealed, claiming that the district court improperly placed the burden of proof on petitioner and that the district court's factual findings were clearly erroneous. The court affirmed and held that, although it agreed that the burden of proof under the statute was on the lien claimant, the court found that the district court's ruling was properly based on the evidence presented by the lien claimant, respondent, and on the failure of petitioner to allege proper grounds for relief under the statute.